Why is there nothing like MMO guilds for Social media?
Some of the absolute most fun I had being online was when I was playing MMOs. I have always been someone who prefers single player games. I like games in similar ways to how I like reading fiction and watching movies. I want a good story, interesting characters and fun world to explore and gameplay that requires me to at least pay attention and gives me the feeling of learning a new skill.
I have played multiplayer games like Battlefield and some other shooters, but they never hooked me for long. Starcraft 2 Ranked, League of Legends (LOL) and a number of MMOs are very clear exceptions. I played LOL mostly because I liked the character designs and the cool videos Riot posted on their Youtube channel for each new character. I kept playing it because I learned I enjoyed PWNING NOOBS :D, especially when they complained in chat. I stopped playing because the game was negatively influencing my mood way to much (I also was a little noob), if I lost 1 or 2 games the rest of my evening was ruined. That did not seem healthy so a few months before I started University (to study Game Engineering), I stopped and have never played the game since. Since stopping I have never really felt any interest in downloading the game again, the experience of playing it is just not something I miss.
That is not the case for some of the MMOs I played. I have spent years playing World of Warcraft (WoW), Archeage and Black Desert all at different moments in my life but mostly during high school. Not all games hooked me in the same way.
World of Warcraft hooked me because it took place in world of Warcraft III, the game that opened my eyes to how games can use gameplay as a narrative tool which was so cool to me. I also was very much drawn to the world and the stories Blizzard tell in that world with some really cool characters.

Playing WoW allowed me to learn more about that fantastical world Blizzard had created and participate in stories that to me were just as or sometimes even more interesting than the fantasy books I enjoyed reading. If I was not playing the game I was watching videos from Noble87. He made (and looks like still is) videos about the stories told in World of Warcraft. Watching his videos made me enjoy the game even more, because how cool is it that a game is able to get someone to make video after video telling the stories from characters in the game. That a game can spark that in someone seemed just so incredibly cool to me.
The world and its stories were not the only aspects of the game that kept me playing, WoW like most other MMOs has raids. Big hours long game play sections that aim to not only test the skills of the players but their ability to work together. Raids require the players to find a group of players with different 'roles', there are Healers, damage dealers and Tanks. In order to participate in the raid you need at least 1 healer, 1 tank and a few damage dealers, everyone needs to understand how to plat their role in order for the group to succeed. Each raid has encounters with enemies you do not encounter in other places when playing the game. To win those encounters you need to learn to read the attacks of the bosses that you need to fight. They will 'telegraph' how they will attack so you and your group need to learn how those attacks work in order to win. At the most basic level the Tank i your group will need to make sure all attacks are focused on them, the healer will need to keep the Tank (and everyone else) alive so they only have to worry about the damage dealers not being attacked so they can focus on defeating all the enemies including the big boss. There will be moments during most boss fights where everyone needs to do a certain action in order for the boss to be defeated, this can be moving to a certain place in the arena, destroying certain objects or making sure the smaller enemies are defeated first.

Participating in a raid is not unlike doing team sports. You know your own capabilities and if you know the people in your group the capabilities of your team and work together within the rules of the game to win. Which like with team sports requires communicating, watching out for each other and pushing each other to do their best.
Playing WoW I participated in raids with random people I did not know, which was often quite difficult. Most players will do a raid multiple times to get all the rewards exclusive to that raid, so when you play with people who you have never met before you do not know who has done the raid before and knows what to do. So you will often see someone trying to convince the group that they know best and everyone should follow their instructions. If that goes well the raid will be fine, if not it will spiral into chaos with everyone pointing fingers for each mistake made often ending in people leaving the raid or everyone defeated by the enemies in what is called a 'party wipe'. I have experienced many of these also participating in the discussions trying to get everyone to do what I think is the best course of action of mediating between players in the group who were mad at each other to try and get them to work together. It is fascinating to look back at those experiences, I honestly think games provide a great way to experience such social interactions that reflect similar situation you might experience in real life but with much lower stakes. Learning how to work together with people you do not know is a great skill to learn at a young age, but doing raids with friends is so much more fun. I have had many long weekendnights at friends houses doing raid after raid trying to perfect our teamwork and make sure all of us get the rewards we want from the raid, which often meant doing it again and again after I already had everything I wanted.
The world and the stories of WoW made me want to try the game, but it was the social aspects that got me to level multiple characters to lvl 80 (which requires many many hours of playing). But the big social feature most MMOs provide, the Guild system, was not something I engaged with when playing WoW, I was introduced to the absolute incredible system provided by guilds when I started playing a MMO called Archeage. After playing WoW I started looking for other MMOs that provided a similar experience in a different finctional world. I dropped most after a few weeks, because they lacked in either gameplay, story, interesting characters or seemed more like interactive slot machine rather than a fully fledged out game. While Archeage very much had some of those same slot machine features, the gameplay was great a lot better than I was used to from WoW. But what got me distracted from the more money grubbing aspects of Archeage was the guild system. As in other MMOs in Archeage you go around the world doing tasks (called quests) like defeating a number of critters and collecting certain items. While doing those tasks you often encounter other players. That is what happened when I was playing Archeage too. I encountered one player because I was learning what was needed in order to buy a house in the game, that was one of the cool features you did not have in WoW, at least not when I played it. Unfortunately this was difficult to do without spending real money which was something I was not willing to do. I met other players complaining about this and we decided to work together to get the necessary items and in-game money to get in order to acquire a house in the game. The other players were part of a Guild, basically a in-game association you can join as a member. Being a member allows you to meet other players who are part of that Guild and work together to complete certain goals unique to Guilds. This can be collecting certain items or joining people from the guild on raids (most MMOs have something similar to the raids in WoW). Other players from the guild decided to help me acquire a house, which was such a cool and impactful experience for me at the time.

People I had never met were willing to spend hours of their time to help a complete stranger to complete a totally meaningless goal of acquiring some pure virtual wealth. Of course that experience made me want to be like to helpful strangers and once I had my little virtual abode help other players in the Guild acquire one for themselves.

In short I was hooked, playing Archeage was no longer about playing that game it was about spending time with my new friends. After some time I felt it was safe to join their Teamspeak rooms to not only talk to my fellow guildmembers using the in-game chat but really talk to them in a voice chat room. There I learned about the person behind the character of the game. I remember being quite nervous about talking in the voice chat, because of all the insecurities normal for most 14 to 16 year olds. But this allowed me to actually feel like we were friends. Most conversations were about in-game events, the only thread that connected us was the game. But because of the lower barriers to say something in a voice chat I would have some conversations about real life stuff, but I don't remember having many of those. But it showed that people who are willing to spend hours of their time to help a stranger they met online are actually really nice, surprise surprise.
Before I compared participating in raids to playing a team sport, being part of a guild is very similar to being a member of a sport association. It comes with making sure new members understand the Guilds 'culture' and try to motivate everyone to help achieving the Guilds goals. Being an active member of the Guild changed how I experienced the game. It showed me a side of gaming that is absent in other games even if they allow you to play with other people like WoW.
Playing the game becomes not only a form of hanging out, it creates meaning for everything you do, it allows you to feel part of something bigger than yourself. Unfortunately, even the Guild was not enough for me to keep playing after a certain point. As you can imagine being an active member and trying to stay active takes a lot of time. Time I would also like to spend on other games and on things not related to games at all, so I started logging in less and less and eventually deleted the game. But the experience of being part of a Guild is something that I miss to this day almost 15 years later.
After Archeage I experienced it again when I played another MMO called Black Desert. Again I was just playing the game as normal, unlike MMOs like WoW and Archeage, Black Desert lends itself well to be played like an single player game up to a certain point at least. The gameplay is fantastic and feels almost like a fighting game with how you can connect moves to create combos. It also has a cool unique feature where you connect certain locations to slowly create an entire trading network. But like Archeage and WoW it does have a guild system.
One day just running through the world of Black Desert I noticed a name I recognised and after a slightly awkward conversation that started by me asking the person behind the character with the name I recognised "what other games do you play that I could know you from?" I realised I knew that name from Archeage, he even was one of the leaders of the guild in Archeage. Years later in a different game I found him and other people from the guild that stopped playing Archeage and started another guild in Black Desert, they kept in contact after most of them stopped playing Archeage. So of course I joined again and this time also joined the Discord which by then had replaced Teamspeak for using voice chat during gaming sessions. It was basically the same as it was during our time playing Archeage but in a different MMO.

It was in a another game so it was all a little different, but again we were working together to help each other got to our personal goals in the game, which was something that made playing Black Desert a lot more enjoyable because to get anything done in that game could take enormous amount of time.
Again the Guild system brought people together and gave meaning to what the member of the guild tried to achieve. Realizing how video game systems like this can get complete strangers work together and set goals to further the group they are part of. Most Guild systems made it easy for player to track how their playtime translated to furthering the goals of the Guild. Like in Black Desert collecting certain items by for example creating those trading networks mentioned earlier would provide everyone in the Guild with effects that would make them stronger making it easier for them to complete certain goals. Or how Jane McGonigal puts it in her book Reality is Broken quoting Bernard Suits:
Playing a game is the voluntary attempt to overcome unnecessary obstacles
I love that quote. Also highly recommend the book, it is a large reason why I decided to study Game Engineering and later Interaction Technology, it is full of information about how systems in most video games and games in general (including sports) somehow manage to direct human behavior to do phenomenal things that have no real meaning outside of the game, but provide the players with real intrinsic rewards and real positive emotions which do have real world effects outside of the game.
I have wondered if providing the 'unnecessary obstacles' outside of a game in for example a social media platform could be done in a way that would get users to want to voluntarily overcome them. I do not have the solution for how this can be achieved or what good unnecessary obstacles could be on a social media platform, but I do think it is worth trying to figure out. I do not know how, but I do feel that ATProto might just be a good way to create these unnecessary obstacles and a Guild like system that brings people together to try and solve them.
I do not know what this blog will become, even this post became different than I first had intented before I started writing. I wanted to write much more about ways games direct human behaviour, but decided to look at that aspect from a higher level by describing my experiences playing MMOs.
If you made it this far, I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart for reading it. I am very new to blogging and writing in general. I notice I find it difficult to find the right words to get my thoughts across, which is why I want to write more. I have many thoughts and ideas, I hope by writing them down in posts like this I will become better at communicating them and make them more well rounded. I think a good followup for this post could be one that explores features of different guild systems and how they work to get players to perform certain in-game tasks. I will write them and I hope you will keep reading them and engage with them if you agree or disagree with them.
Do you accept that quest?